Ashok Sinha: Is London the 'best big city in the world'?

London Cycling Campaign chief executive Ashok Sinha asks if the capital’s standing is improving against other big cities.

Is London the ‘best big city in the world’? Much depends on how you define ‘best’ and ‘big’. Nevertheless, that pinnacle is the goal Mayor Boris Johnson has set for the capital, which tends to suggest he doesn’t think London is the best just yet. (Trivia alert: London is around the 25th largest city in the world, depending on how you measure it; Birmingham, the UK’s second largest, ranks about 150th).

But if London isn’t the best big city in the world, then why not? Boris will have his own criteria (which quite normally for politicians of all stripes he has kept vague), so maybe we should posit our own. Even if you don’t buy into all this political machismo (my skyscrapers are taller than your skyscrapers) there are good reasons to ask what it is that we can do to make London the best it can be for everyone who lives and works here, and for everyone who passes through it. (Or indeed for anybody, anywhere, who is affected by London’s international reach — from the financial markets to our carbon emissions.)

Latest indicators for London
One set of candidate benchmarks was published last month by the London Sustainable Development Commission (not to be confused with its UK namesake, set up in the early Blair years and sacrificed in the coalition government’s bonfire of the quangos). Most readers will probably never have heard of it or will be hazy as to what it does, but for over a decade the LSDC has been beavering away in City Hall, establishing indicators for London’s ‘sustainability’ and assessing progress in relation to them.

And for the wonks: the LSDC uses a reworking of the UN’s classical definition of Sustainable Development, namely “ensuring we have a better quality of life now and for the future, whilst protecting and enhancing the Earth’s resources”. Just in case you were wondering.

The latest issuing from the Commissioners — who are a mix of folk from public agencies, business, the NGO world and politics — is entitled London’s Quality of Life Indicators 2012. It spans (take a deep breath, which you should because, apparently, our air quality is getting better — but more of that later) no fewer than 33 environmental, social and economic indicators, including politically charged issues such as crime and housing affordability. Each indicator has one or more numerical measures attached (eg traffic volume is quantified in billions of vehicle-kms per annum) with a traffic light system to indicate trends to the good or ill.

If so inclined, I’d recommend you have a look at it for yourselves. Cycling itself isn’t an indicator (I’ll come back to that), but there are indicators that are relevant to the experiences and concerns of cyclists: it may not feel like it when sat in a cloud of diesel fumes but our air quality has improved (if still woefully short of what Londoners deserve and what EU regulations require); travel to school by bike is up (but the proportion walking to school has declined) and motor traffic volumes are falling (although a quick delve into TfL data shows substantial regional variation, with central London experiencing the greatest falls compared to virtually unchanged volumes in outer London).

The good news headline is that 17 of the 33 indicators are on a positive trend (ignoring any weighting conundrums: are income inequality and volunteering rate equally important, for example?), although areas of deterioration such as increasing voter apathy, decreasing business survival rates and increasing fuel poverty are of serious concern.

Cycling’s wider impact
So, even if only from a cycling perspective, we should be pleased, right? Well yes we should, insofar as cyclists are breathing (slightly) cleaner air and jostling with (a modicum) less motor traffic. But should we be satisfied? Of course not. We know road danger — real or perceived — is the main barrier to people cycling more or at all, and this is suppressing the huge latent demand there is for cycling and hence all benefits cycling brings. Which leads to a broader point. It may sound parochial but I’d argue that the proportion of journeys made by bike should be identified as a key sustainable development indicator by itself. Here at LCC we genuinely believe, as we said in last year’s Love London, Go Dutch campaign, that our city will be made “more liveable for everyone” by making our streets as “safe and inviting for cycling” as they are in the Netherlands.

On that basis, action to promote cycling then becomes a means for achieving other sustainable development outcomes (eg lower ecological footprint and higher employment rates) not just a goal in itself. As Boris himself said not so long ago, cycling is “arguably the single most important tool for making London the best big city in the world”.

We wholeheartedly agree.


This article first appeared in the April / May 2013 issue of London Cyclist magazine, delivered free to LCC members every two months.


  • By zilky at 8:13am 29 January 2015

I have bookmarked this page for future use.keep blogging.i'm positive my devotees will discover this article truly valuable

food stamps free phone
  • By zilky at 2:15pm 14 February 2015

What is the name of the layout incidentally? I was considering utilizing this style for the site I am going to develop for my school venture.

My site here
  • By zilky at 8:36am 22 February 2015

Also great blog here with all of the valuable information you have. Keep up the good work you are doing here.

cloud accounting software
  • By zilky at 7:03am 25 February 2015

Additionally, I made a point to bookmark your site so I can return later. I appreciated exceptionally well perusing this post.

plombier cormeilles en parisis
  • By alex12 at 8:55am 25 February 2015

Consulta de Ginecología y Obstetricia en Madrid tratan las necesidades de las mujeres en todas las etapas de la vida, en la adolescencia, el embarazo, la menopausia y más allá.Proporcionar asistencia sanitaria para mujeres que requiere de una sensibilidad especial, en la Clínica DAM somos conscientes de ello y nos aseguramos de trabajar con profesionales competentes y atentos a las necesidades especiales de nuestras clientes.Cómo no, realizamos también todos los procesos de control y seguimiento del embarazo, para la detección temprana de problemas en el feto, siempre asegurando los cuidados necesarios para la madre.Ginecologos

  • By alex12 at 11:59am 27 February 2015

Linking is very useful have really helped lots of people who visit blog and provide them usefull information.SEO Conference

  • By zilky at 8:03am 3 March 2015

This is exceptionally Great and decent post for Mac client. I got a great deal of data from this site.
  • By alex12 at 10:52am 8 March 2015

City Hall, establishing indicators for London’s ‘sustainability’ and assessing progress in relation to them.Zofran heart defect

Really amazing blog, I’d love to discover some extra information. pest control pros

It's not my very first time to visit this blog; I’m visiting this daily and acquire superb info from here day by day. termopasta

There is obviously a lot to know about this. I think you made some good points in Features also.

the LSDC has been beavering away in City Hall, establishing indicators for London’s ‘sustainability’ and assessing progress in relation to them.

recumbent exercise bike

your articles about london cycling and events are great always appreciated by the team members. Thanks for the sharing easter sunday 2015 april fools pranks

Post a reply

Sign in to post a reply.