TfL abandons flawed Lambeth roundabout in favour of trial of Dutch cycling design

Transport for London has decided not to proceed with its flawed proposal for the northern Lambeth Bridge roundabout, instead trialling a Dutch-style design suggested by us and other campaigners.

You can see how the roundabout works in the video above made by Dutch expert Mark Wagenbuur who blogs at Bicycle Dutch.

An off-street Dutch-style roundabout with segregated cycle lanes is being built at the Transport Research Laboratory in Berkshire, where its safety and effectiveness will be tested by British engineers.

These roundabouts are extremely commonplace in the Netherlands, where they provide safety and convenience for people riding bicycles.

A workshop hosted by ourselves and the Dutch Cycling Embassy established that there is space for a Dutch roundabout at Lambeth Bridge

TfL's original design kept the dangerous two-lane entries to the roundabout, which encourage high speed motor traffic, and also proposed shared-use cycling and walking zones around the outside of the roundabout.

The idea was that 'fast' cyclists would share roadspace with the fast-moving motor traffic, while 'slow' ones would use the shared-use area, away from motor traffic.

Why most people won't use the shared use facility

Sadly, this type of design fails to provide a useful cycling facility for 90% of Londoners.

The shared-use facility would be too slow and inconvenient for anyone cycling at normal speed (12-15mph).

It's also potentially dangerous for these 'slow' cyclists to rejoin the carriageway into a stream of motor traffic immediately after the roundabout.

And mixing cyclists and pedestrians in a shared space on what's likely to be a commuter route also has the potential to cause conflict.

Why most people won't cycle on the carriageway

The two-tier approach from TfL envisaged 'fast' cyclists riding with motor traffic on a roundabout not dissimilar to the existing layout.

However, surveys have revealed many times that most Londoners are too scared to cycle in close proximity to fast-moving motor traffic.

For that reason, the assumption that a two-lane roundabout is adequate for cycling is flawed.

Replies

  • By GeorgeG at 2:17pm 11 January 2013
I like the design, but am wondering whether cars at Lambeth Bridge will give way to bikes anywhere near as cheerfully as they seem to in the Dutch video.
  • By Label at 3:23pm 11 January 2013

Lambeth bridge has zebra crossings at every entrance, unlik the roundabout in the video, which should help facilitate a "give way" mentality among drivers. Plus there are so many cyclists using it at rush hour that sheer force of numbers would probably get the message across - usually no fewer than 10/minute passing through heading East in the mornings, West in the evenings. 

Lambeth bridge is on my daily commute and it's a nightmare. The traffic races round at normal road speeds so you're forced to stop and then hurtle off as fast as you can. It's not pleasant. 

Although I am a very keen supporter of go-dutch and segragated lanes whereever possible I am not sure this is a good example. 

The video does not have a lot of bike or car traffic. In the rush hour at Lambeth there could be a continuous flow of bikes which would result in a major traffic jam. there could even be cars jammed on the cycel paths as they can't get onto and off the roundabout.

Does anyone have an exampe of this sort of Dutch roundabout with traffic flow similar to Lambeth?

  • By bigpete at 8:37pm 11 January 2013

This is genuine progress. I'm relieved that TfL have dropped their deeply flawed proposal.

I'm not sure whether the news that they are going to test segregated cycle lanes in a laboratory is sign that British transport planners are finally taking cycling seriously or whether it's simply a case of Not Invented Here!

  • By anita at 1:27pm 12 January 2013

Are English drivers perhaps still too infantile for the Dutch-style roundabout? Would they give priority to cyclists?

  • By Amoeba at 8:34am 13 January 2013

To get the full benefit of high-quality cycling infrastructure, it needs to form a continuous network. A patchwork of islands of 'good practice' separated by an ocean of hostile roads is unlikely to achieve anything significant.

Imagine a stretch of motorway with no access for motor-vehicles. It wouldn't be used because nobody could! Safe bicycle infrastructure accessible only by hostile roads is little different.

The detractors will predictably claim: 'see, we built it and they didn't come'.

At such times, it's important to remember the often downright mendacious and crepidatious 'reportage' (aka 'spin') about the alleged dangers resulting from 20 mph limits. It was debunked by BBC Radio Four's 'More or Less' programme. Listen from 12.20 onwards.

http://downloads.bbc.co.uk/podcasts/radio4/moreorless/moreorless_20120817-1630a.mp3

 

Promising. I'd like to know if they will be advised by Dutch experts during the lab trial, and if not why not, but I can't work out what they expect to achieve by trialling it where they can't get the same type and density of road user (much as raymondox comments on the situation in the video). The general effectiveness has already been proven in the Netherlands. I reckon they should just build it and see what happens - if going Dutch is an option to them, they'll have to bite the bullet at some point.

@raymondox - I think you'd get the jams when they were building it:  the period of installation would give people the chance to find alternative ways to get around the area before it was fully operational (bicycle perhaps?).

Well, we have to start somehwere, so this could perhaps be it. Although I am not sure that I will trust drivers to give way in the first few months, especially as it is not backed by the sort of Dutch legislation that makes drivers in Holland very careful not to hit cyclists (or pedestrians) - I shall be very circumspect on it...But this is extremely encouraging.

  • By zilky at 4:37pm 15 February 2015

I won't reconsider to embrace your blog entry to anyone who needs and needs help about this zone.

My web resource
  • By AsharSeo at 7:20am 16 February 2015

 I truly admire your hard work. I trust you continue composing these sorts of article. Much obliged.

free credit report gov

Η διαδικασία των μεταφορών και των μετακομίσεων έχει πάει σε τέτοιο επίπεδο στις μέρες μας που στις περισσότερες περιπτώσεις συμφέρει να φέρεις ένα αντικείμενο απο άλλη πόλη ή περιοχή ακόμη και απο το να επιλέξεις και να μεταφέρεις το αντικέιμενο μόνος σου ακόμη και απο τη γειτονιά σου. 

ganoderma
  • By zilky at 2:24pm 19 February 2015

I am really aroused by this excellent stuff. I always prefer to read the quality content and this thing I found in you post. Thanks for sharing

enterprise cloud software provider
  • By zilky at 1:49pm 22 February 2015

Great article, it was very helpufl! I just started in this and I'm getting to know it better! Cheers, keep up the good work!

accounting software
  • By alex12 at 2:07pm 25 February 2015

Laboratorio de análisis clínicos en Clínica DAM, calle Marqués de Jura Real, 12, 28019 Madrid, teléfono 91 460 80 00.Más del 70 por ciento de todas las decisiones de salud se basan en la información vital proporcionada por los análisis clínicos realizados en los laboratorios.Nuestro servicio al cliente atiende con rapidez sus demandas sobre el estado de los análisis, instrucciones sobre manipulación de especímenes o petición de análisis.Laboratorio de Analisis Clinicos

  • By zilky at 3:02pm 25 February 2015

Good luck for the following! I like the important data you give in your articles.

depannage plombier saint mande
  • By zilky at 3:20pm 28 February 2015

I need to discover an article with important data on this subject and give the instructor our conclusion and the article.

zcode sports betting
  • By alex12 at 5:51pm 28 February 2015

Berkshire, where its safety and effectiveness will be tested by British engineers.Vegas SEO conference

I manage to include your blog among my reads every day because you have compelling entries that I look forward to

temporary resident permit

Those that are offensive or abusive will be edited or removed and we reserve the right to suspend the accounts of users posting such material..

car rental jaipur to delhi

Inside our traditions we have now adapted that engineering you can get for everyone. We many possess connection to the internet with the computer programs ..

hosting24 coupon code 2015

Đồng hồ đeo tay nữ thời trang sẽ làm cho đôi tay của các bạn nữ một dấu ấn khó phai. Trẻ em hay các khách hàng trong độ tuổi đi học sẽ tìm được những mẫu đồng hồ dành đúng cho lứa tuổi của mình. Tất cả đều có tại Đồng hồ Rexy.

dong ho deo tay nam

It's also potentially dangerous for these 'slow' cyclists to rejoin the carriageway into a stream of motor traffic immediately after the roundabout.

exped air pillow

Glad to chat your blog, I seem to be forward to more reliable articles and I think we all wish to thank so many good articles, blog to share with us.

start a blog on wordpress

segregated cycle lanes is being built at the Transport Research Laboratory in Berkshire, where its safety and effectiveness will be tested by British engineers.

http://kptv.com/story/27971908/girlfriend-activation-system-review-teaches-obsession-story-secrets-steps-of-gfas-v2
  • By Tomm at 8:46pm 20 March 2015
It was nice to read this well written article. www.googlesniper30.com

Auf über 300 m2 Fläche nden wir für Ihre Kunstwerke, Bilder und Fotos den passenden Rahmen, mit oder ohne Passepartout. Unsere top ausgestatte Rahmenwerkstatt ermöglicht uns schnell und in höchster Qualität auf jeden Kundenwunsch zu reagieren.


Galerieschienen

Der Schwerpunkt unseres Angebots liegt in der Konzeption, Gestaltung und Entwicklung von Websites sowie im Online Marketing..

list of email address

which from its founding was more tolerant to Jews than most countries in Europe, Christian trade and craft guilds in many cities excluded Jewish merchants and artisans.

jaipur to delhi cab

which encourage high speed motor traffic, and also proposed shared-use cycling and walking zones around the outside of the roundabout.

bauchspeicheldrusenkrebs lebenserwartung

That is very interesting Smile I love reading and I Cipto Junaedy always searching for informative information like this Jadwal MotoGP 2015. This is exactly what I was looking for Cara Upload Video ke Youtube.  Really this system so amazing. Cipto Junaedy  so happy to browsing this BBM Untuk Android Versi Terbaru. Simply fill out a quick and easy application, and you'll be on your way to getting your new Cara Membuat Email  and Cara Instal Windows 7 avoiding Thanks for sharing this great article . Don't forget for reading the articles about Jinpoker.com Agen Judi Poker Online dan Domino Online Indonesia Terpercaya. And I encourage you to bookmark the following page if Cahayapoker.com Agen Judi Poker Dan Domino Uang Asli Online Terpercaya Indonesia considered important ... Regards

Post a reply

Sign in to post a reply.